View more on these topics

Richard Buxton: Never mind Brexit, stand by for President Trump

Buxton Richard Old Mutual

Let’s be charitable and blame the referendum. Most investors – in the UK, at least – appear so fixated by the gyrations of opinion polls they regard the prospect of Donald Trump actually becoming the next president of the US as laughable. The hair, the outrageous remarks on women, Muslims and foreigners. Populist ravings, wacky policies. Surely a landslide for Hilary Clinton?

But let’s pause for a moment’s reflection. Trump has been dismissed as an entertaining no-hoper throughout, a distraction until the Republican Party came to its senses. He stands now on the brink of endorsement as their presidential candidate. At the very least, this demands investors do more than shrug or laugh.

When I studied politics at school (rather longer ago than I care to remember) British and American politics were markedly different. The Labour party was socialist, believing in state ownership of the “commanding heights” of the economy, trade union-financed and representative of “the working class”. The Conservatives were capitalist, supported a smaller state, a market-driven economy, and spoke for the upper and middle classes.

In the US, by contrast, Democrats and Republicans were both firmly for capitalism, enterprise and the American Dream. “The business of America is business” – policy differences over more or less liberal attitudes were highly nuanced in comparison with British political divides.

Fast forward to today and a remarkable transformation has occurred. Tony Blair’s New Labour and his three election victories are but one example of the fact Britain’s two main parties now converge in their battle for the middle ground.

George Osborne unashamedly steals policies from the Labour manifesto. Voters soundly rejected Ed Miliband’s turn to the left, hence widespread incredulity at Jeremy Corbyn’s leadership. The contest now is over whom best manages the market economy for the benefit of those much-cited “hard-working families”, not between socialist and capitalist models.

But while Labour and the Conservatives have converged over the last 40 years, Democrats and Republicans appear to have diverged. Business is highly critical of Democrat interference in the market economy. Clinton’s opponent, Bernie Sanders, sounds near-socialist at times, while both appear quite happy with growing government influence.

Republicans, meanwhile, have drifted to the right, nudged by characters such as Newt Gingrich and Sarah Palin, demonising Democrat healthcare reforms. The result? Swathes of middle America do not feel either party really represents their common interests any more.

Add in the well-publicised stagnation in US middle and lower incomes over 20 years and there is ample scope for an outsider to appeal to disenfranchised voters with their version of capitalist Republicanism. Step forward Donald Trump.

And there is profound personal mistrust of Hilary Clinton. Tarnished by one mistake too many, incapable of presenting neither fresh novelty appeal nor a return to her husband’s “golden age” of growth and prosperity, she is no shoe-in.

At the very least, there must be a reasonable chance that, at some stage before 8 November, markets have to address even the possibility of President Trump. To date, they do not appear to have done so.

And what might that mean? Accepting that much campaign rhetoric will be ditched before being sworn in or prove difficult to steer through Congress, this cannot be good for world trade. Renegotiation of trade deals, accusing China (and possibly Germany) of being a currency manipulator and facing protectionist sanctions is not appealing to one brought up on the mantra of globalisation and free trade.

Equally, though, it is unclear that a country the size of China can maintain a mercantilist model as smaller nations have previously. It must accelerate closures of excess capacity in the likes of coal, steel and cement, and spur its growth of a consumer and services-driven economy. Sanctions might speed up the process.

Reductions in corporate and personal tax rates plus deficit-financed infrastructure investment do not sound good for US government debt levels, even if the trade deficit shrank alongside world trade.

Governmental oversight of the Federal Reserve might be a policy too far for investors, though perversely the infrastructure spending would probably overheat a US economy close to full employment. So the Fed might be raising rates alongside the dollar rising just when you might think its appeal was waning.

A one-off low tax amnesty on US companies repatriating cash to the US might fuel a merger and acquisition feeding frenzy on Wall Street.

And then there is scaling back US support for Nato, less interest in the Middle East but more defence spending and greater pushback on Chinese naval ambitions. Less global policeman? Or different global policeman?

In honesty, we do not know the answers to what a Trump presidency might mean. And quite probably neither does Trump himself. Reality is usually less dramatic than feared anticipation.

But it is worth thinking about – and seeing if the markets do, too. Now, where’s that latest Brexit opinion poll…

Richard Buxton is head of UK equities and manager of the Old Mutual UK Alpha fund


EU Flags European Union 480

Where has the £65bn Brexit cash gone?

Outflows sparked by the possibility of Brexit might take longer to return to the UK as more market uncertainties take their toll on investors, experts are predicting. Some £65bn has been pulled out of the UK in March and April amid growing uncertainty over the EU membership referendum, Bank of England figures show. The Bank […]


FTSE dives as Brexit fears take hold

The FTSE index has dropped 6 per cent in the past four days as pollsters showed a vote to Brexit has become more likely. The FTSE 100 ended the day down 2 per cent yesterday, at 5,923, the lowest point for the index since February. Yesterday marked the fourth day of losses for the index as fears […]

The curious market reaction to Brexit

Written by Mike Riddell29 June 2016 Headlines over the past few days have screamed about record falls in sterling, record low bond yields and massive falls in equity prices. However, if you take a slightly longer view of markets rather than simply the one- or two-day reaction, I think it’s amazing how little markets have […]


News and expert analysis straight to your inbox

Sign up


There is one comment at the moment, we would love to hear your opinion too.

  1. A perfect treatise of why we should all vote Remain, to secure a stronger and more united Europe to weather the storms of the Barbarians elsewhere. It also points out quite well how US and UK politics are now broken.

Leave a comment


Why register with Money Marketing ?

Providing trusted insight for professional advisers.  Since 1985 Money Marketing has helped promote and analyse the financial adviser community in the UK and continues to be the trusted industry brand for independent insight and advice.

News & analysis delivered directly to your inbox
Register today to receive our range of news alerts including daily and weekly briefings

Money Marketing Events
Be the first to hear about our industry leading conferences, awards, roundtables and more.

Research and insight
Take part in and see the results of Money Marketing's flagship investigations into industry trends.

Have your say
Only registered users can post comments. As the voice of the adviser community, our content generates robust debate. Sign up today and make your voice heard.

Register now

Having problems?

Contact us on +44 (0)20 7292 3712

Lines are open Monday to Friday 9:00am -5.00pm