Over 60 per cent of absolute return funds failed to produce a positive return in 2011.
The biggest underperformer was the £514m GLG EM credit diversified alternative fund, which fell over 16 per cent. This was followed by the £60m Polar Capital UK absolute return fund, which fell by 13.9 per cent.
Among the underperformers was the flagship BlackRock UK absolute alpha fund. The fund, managed by Mark Lyttleton and Nick Osborne, fell by 6.85 per cent in the 12 months to December 30, 2011.
According to Morningstar, only 25 of the 65 funds in the IMA absolute return sector produced positive returns.
The top performer was the Old Mutual global equity absolute return fund, which returned 11.7 per cent.
Absolute return funds are designed to offer investors a positive return regardless of market conditions. The IMA launched the sector in May 2008 and it has quickly become one of the biggest sellers in the IFA market. Confusion around the definition of absolute return funds has led to an IMA review into the sector. The review is set to conclude in the first half of 2012.
Skerritt Consultants head of investments Andrew Merricks says: “It is disappointing and not a great advertisement for the sector. I do not think the sector needs to change too much and IFAs will simply have to work harder to find the most suitable strategies for them to use.”
10 biggest underperformers in the IMA absolute return sector from 31/12/10 to 30/12/2011
GLG EM Diversified Alternative DN – 16.31 per cent
Polar Capital UK Absolute Return 1 H GBP -13.88 per cent
CF Abs Ret Cau Multi-Asset A Inc -12.26 per cent
GLG Alpha Select Alternative DN GBP -11.37 per cent
L&G European Absolute Trust R Acc -11.11 per cent
SVM UK Absolute Alpha A -10.8 per cent
Aviva Investors UK Absolute Return SC A -9.65 per cent
Smith & Williamson Enterprise E -9.03 per cent
Baring Absolute Return Global Bond A Inc -8.61 per cent
CF TC Absolute Return A Acc -7.01 per cent